Reviews   DVD    Inside Scoop Box Office  Interviews  Features  Contests  Messageboard Search


DVD Main Archive DVD Contests Kids Corner


Treasure Island
Treasure Island (1950)
Movie rating: 7/10
DVD rating: 6/10
Release Date: April 29, 2003
Running Time: 1 hour 36 minutes
Rating: G
Distributor: Walt Disney Home Video
List Price: $29.99
American Red Cross volunteers have been deployed to the hardest hit areas of Katrina’s destruction, supplying hundreds of thousands victims left homeless with critical necessities. By making a financial gift to Hurricane 2005 Relief, the Red Cross can provide shelter, food, counseling and other assistance to those in need.

DONATE HERE

Disc Details
Special Features: Full frame format
Chapter selection
Sneak peeks
Video Format: Full Frame (1.33:1)
[SS-SL]
Languages: English (Dolby Digital 5.1)
Subtitles: English for the hearing impared.
Captions: Yes
Casing: 1-Disc Keep Case

Review
"Treasure Island" was Walt Disney's first live action feature film. While the Technicolor photography is beautiful, I can't help but yearn for Victor Fleming's 1934 Black and White version. In the Fleming version, Wallace Beery created a Long John Silver that couldn't be surpassed. That said, the Disney version is entertaining.

Based on Robert Louis Stevenson's adventure classic, "Treasure Island" tells the tale of a fatherless boy caught up in a world of pirates. Jim Hawkins (Bobby Driscoll) works for Captain Billy Bones. Bones is a retired pirate who is hiding from his old shipmates. They have caught up with him. As the old pirate lays dying, he gives Jim his treasure map. Jim takes it to Squire Trelawney (Walter Fitzgerald), who immediately begins to put a crew together to find the island. The Squire hires a cook, Long John Silver (Robert Newton). Silver assures the Squire that he can put a crew together, and he does.

The heart of "Treasure Island" is the relationship between the fatherless Jim Hawkins and the pirate Long John Silver. Silver manipulates the boy and befriends him. In the end, the pirate betrays the boy for gold. What worked in the original, fails in the Disney version. Wallace Beery and Jackie Cooper bonded as Long John Silver and Jim. You felt the turmoil as Jim realizes that John is not his friend. Cooper's performance is spectacular. In the Disney version, Bobby Driscoll is a pure heart who has no trouble turning Long John Silver into the Squire. Mr. Lawson also fails to generate the humanity that Mr. Beery did in the role. Mr. Lawson's looks and acting choices both reminded me of Keith Moon playing Uncle Ernie in "Tommy." This is a huge failure on part of the filmmakers.

The Disc
Fair movie. Great picture and sound. No extras. A bit high priced for a vanilla DVD.

Picture Quality: 10/10
Disney restored the movie for this DVD. Oscar winning cinematographer (and Hammer horror movie director) Freddie Francis captured some beautiful Technicolor images. The picture is lush with deeply saturated colors. Some of the best uses of shadows and darkness in a color film as you are likely to see. No artifacts or pixilation. Sharp images all the way to the edges.

Sound Quality: 8/10
At times the high range is a bit flat. Otherwise, the soundtrack is crisp and clear. At times the movie makes good use of the surround sound features. No loss of dialogue. Nice integration of the bass into the rest of the track.

Easter Eggs:
No Easter Eggs found during review.

Extra Features: 0/10
There are no extras on this disk. There are Sneak Peeks for a number of other Disney films.

The Final Word:
It is a shame that this DVD is so high priced. It is a vanilla DVD. I don't care if it is a quality transfer by Walt Disney. The DVD should not cost more that $19.95. Worth the price of a rental for those who've never seen the Wallace Beery/Jackie Cooper version.

Rusty White

Sponsored by:

Visit them at:
Disney.com


return to top